I'm new to the board and the finances confuse me. Where do I start?
· Erik Reagan · 3 min read
Start here: you were not recruited to be an accountant. If the board wanted another accountant, it would have asked for one. You were asked because of judgment, or connections, or a perspective the board was missing — and none of that requires you to read a balance sheet fluently on your first night.
What you do need is to know which report answers which question. There are three, they show up in nearly every board packet, and once you can name what each one is for, most of the fog lifts.
The three reports, and the question each answers
Statement of activities — “did we take in more than we spent?” In a for-profit setting this is the income statement or P&L; nonprofits usually call it the statement of activities. It covers a period of time — a month, a quarter, the year so far — and shows revenue on top, expenses below, and the difference at the bottom. That difference is a surplus or a deficit. Read the bottom line, then read the two or three largest lines above it, because those are where the story actually lives.
Statement of financial position — “what do we own and what do we owe?” The balance sheet, in other words. This one is a snapshot on a single date, not a period. Assets on one side, liabilities on the other, and what’s left over is net assets. The line most boards should watch here is cash: how much is there, and how many months of expenses would it cover if revenue stopped tomorrow.
One nonprofit-specific wrinkle worth learning early: net assets come in two flavors, with donor restrictions and without. Money a donor gave for the scholarship fund cannot pay the electric bill, even though it sits in the same bank account. A healthy-looking cash balance that’s mostly restricted is not the same as a healthy cash balance.
Budget versus actual — “are we where we said we’d be?” This is the one board members can usually read fastest and often skip. It puts the approved budget next to what actually happened, and shows the gap. It’s the closest thing a board gets to a steering report: the other two tell you where you are, this one tells you whether you’re drifting off the course you approved.
Four questions that make you useful immediately
You don’t need to interpret the numbers. You need to ask about them. These four work at nearly any board meeting, in any organization:
“How many months of operating expenses do we have in cash?” The single most clarifying financial question a volunteer board member can ask. Everything else is context for this.
“Which line is furthest from budget, and why?” It moves the conversation from reading numbers aloud to explaining them, which is where a board’s actual oversight happens.
“Is that number a one-time thing or does it repeat?” A surprise gift and a new recurring expense look identical on a monthly report and mean completely different things.
“What are you watching that isn’t on this page yet?” Ask the treasurer or the executive director. The answer is almost always the most valuable thing said about finances all evening.
Say the sentence
Here’s the permission you may be waiting for: “I don’t understand this line — can you walk me through it?” is not an admission of anything. It is a service to the whole board.
Financial reports get discussed at a speed set by the two most fluent people in the room. Everyone else nods. When you stop the room and ask, you are almost never the only one who needed it — you’re just the one willing to say so. Boards that make that question normal make better decisions, because more than three people understand what they’re deciding.
Two other things help more than they should. Ask the treasurer for thirty minutes over coffee and have them walk you through last month’s packet line by line; treasurers are usually delighted to be asked. And if your organization files a full Form 990, read the last one — it’s a public document, written in plainer language than the financials, and a surprisingly good tour of the whole organization. (Very small organizations file a short electronic notice instead, which won’t tell you much; ask the treasurer which one applies.)
Give it three or four meetings. The reports stop being a wall of numbers and start being a story with characters you recognize. That’s the whole learning curve, and it’s shorter than you think.